December 16, 2002

John Stark Associates

Volume 5
Number 9

Page 1
- Welcome
Page 2
- Update
Page 3
- News
Page 4
- Brief lines

* Welcome *
Welcome to this issue of 2PLM, an e-zine distributed every two weeks on a free subscription basis. This week's article, Please stop howling, is from regular contributor Mike Bryan. Mike's previous article, 'STEP and PDM' can be read in the November 4, 2002 issue.

* Please stop howling *
Apparently, problems with transferring product data up and down the supply chain between heterogeneous CAX systems are proving very costly for companies worldwide. We need to ask ourselves why this should be so - it isn't rocket science. The real problem seems to be that companies just don't concern themselves very much with quality control of their product data. But this quality control has got to be applied top down not bottom up because it has to permeate the whole organization.

The most valuable resource that any manufacturing company has is its product data, but you wouldn't think so from the cavalier manner in which it is sometimes handled and distributed.

Transferring product data between two disparate systems need not and should not result in any loss of accuracy especially when double precision storage and computation are employed. And neutral representations such as IGES and STEP have sufficient scope such that there should be no loss of data either.

Let's take a look at the exchange process and see where problems occur. First and foremost, does the company operate a CAD construction standard? Then, is the CAD model checked to that standard? In many cases the answer to both of those questions will be NO. OK, so now we have a valid and checked CAD model so we pre-process it into the chosen neutral format.

Have we had this pre-processor quality-checked for compliance with the relevant neutral format standard? Most companies will have to put their hand on their heart and say NO, so they will have no idea if the conversion and approximation algorithms are sound and robust. If they are, then if you start with valid geometry you should finish up with valid geometry.

All of the above reasoning applies to the post-processor stage as well - that is when the neutral format representation is converted into the receiving system. Now it is true that tolerance difference between the two systems can cause difficulties such as self-intersecting solids or gaps in surface geometry - but it really shouldn't. Even poor old IGES has a granularity value embedded in its Global section which should take care of tolerance variations. So, no problems in transferring data between system A and system B.

As we all know, in the automotive and aerospace industries, supply chains can be very long and this, I believe is where the real problems lie. Does the customer always have a view over the whole length of the supply chain - right down to the last jobbing shop that is making simple components like fasteners? After all, it is the customer's valuable product data and he should never lose sight of it.

It is one thing to supervise and quality control the transfer of product data to the first tier suppliers but what happens after that? What generally occurs is that each supplier will take responsibility for transferring data further on down the chain. And really bad things can happen. Most often the SMEs have no data exchange competence and use consultants (who charge a fortune and often don't hold the product data in the same reverence that the original customer does) to do the transfers. So, the customer must oversee and quality control the transfer of product data all the way down the supply chain and even back again when and where that is necessary.

The corporate weeping and wailing over CAD interoperability reminds me of the story of the howling dog who's sitting on a thorn and is just too lazy to get up. Manufacturing Industry uses quality control widely over its processes but not always, seemingly, with respect to its most valuable resource, its product data. So let's get up off the thorn, stop howling and start applying a little quality control where it really matters.

Mike Bryan can be contacted at

Page 2

 ThetisPro - Unified PLM solution
 from Thetis Technologies. Inc.

ThetisPro - Unified PLM solution from Thetis Technologies. Inc.

A Reader Survey
A reader asked if we run surveys. A good question in view of our wide readership. Here's one that could help you to position your Collaborative Product Development (CPD) priorities against the priorities of others. We've made a list of the main areas of CPD interest. If everyone responds by indicating the Top 5 priorities for their company we will be able to form a picture across the different industries.

Please select a link and reply to the survey form hosted by our partner i-nova.cpds. The results will be e-mailed back to all participants.

Survey in English
Survey in French
Survey in German

Reference Section
Follow the link for books in the Product Development Library

Configuration Management . Innovation Management . Performance Metrics . QFD

Proposed ICP-35K Project
In a recent issue we mentioned the proposed "Implementing CPD and PLM Technologies for 35,000 European Manufacturing Companies" project for the Sixth Framework Programme of the European Community for research, technological development and demonstration. The Expression of Interest for the project is on the European Commission's CORDIS web site at

Here is an updated list, by country, of the Consortium members participating in preparation of the proposal:
  • Austria : AVL
  • Belgium : CRIF/WTCM, Decubber Project Associates, KUL, The European Federation of high tech SMEs, Sequoyah
  • Denmark : Teknologisk Institut
  • Finland : Huhtamaki Group, Technia
  • France : Centric Software SAS, CTBA, EADS, i-nova, PSA, Tecnomatix France
  • Germany : ABB, Accenture, BMW Group, Bosch, CAxOPEN, CeTIM (D/NL), DaimlerChrysler, EADS-M, EMC, EPI-K, Fraunhofer Institut, Siemens, TU Dresden, TU Munich, Uni. Bochum, Uni. Kaiserslautern, Uni. Magdeburg, VDI/VDE-IT
  • Greece : Technika Plastika SA, TU Athens
  • Ireland : CIMRU Galway, KineMatik
  • Italy : CR-Fiat, IITA Milan, Politecnico di Milano, think3
  • Netherlands : ADSE, EDS, TNO, TU Eindhoven
  • Norway : EPM Technology, SINTEF
  • Portugal : NLS, Uninova
  • Sweden : Eurostep, IVF
  • Switzerland : ABB, Cadcamation, Charmilles Technologies, CERN, EPFL, HES-SO Geneva, ITI, John Stark Associates, Step-X
  • UK : PDEX, Queen's University, NIAC, Sun Microsystems, Tempest Consulting, Uni. Cardiff, Uni. Edinburgh, Uni. Loughborough, Xerox
  • Malta : Uni. of Malta
  • Poland : OTI Warsaw, IPEA Wroclaw, Uni. Lodz
  • Slovenia : CADING
  • Brasil : UFRGS Porto Alegre
  • In discussion : Access Commerce, ADEPA, Bombardier-Rotax, CostVision, Computer Technologies, Cranfield University, Design Rule, DuPont Europe, IAI, Plexion UK, TU Bergakademie Freiberg.
To achieve a good balance in terms of size, industry, application and geography, we're interested in hearing from other European organisations that may be interested in participating in the project, as well as those that would like to support it without actually participating.

If you're based in the UK or Ireland contact Roger Tempest.

If based in another EU country, or in one of the Candidate Countries, contact John Stark.

Here are two documents that answer frequently asked questions:

Follow the links for :

Vendors in the EDM/PDM/PLM World. Latest additions/modifications : Selerant Corporation.

EDM/PDM/PLM service providers. Latest additions/modifications : DELT ICT Services B.V.

EDM/PDM/PLM Conference and seminar organizations

Conferences and Seminars in the EDM/PDM/PLM world

CE2003 : 10th ISPE International Conference on Concurrent Engineering
Madeira, Portugal. July 26-30, 2003

PTC/USER World Event
Orlando, FL. June 8-11, 2003

ProSTEP Symposium 2003
Ruesselsheim, Germany. May 7-8, 2003

PLM World 2003
Anaheim, CA. April 28 - May 2, 2003

Cambashi Seminar 2003
Gaydon, England. April 9, 2003

Total Design Solutions 2003
Novi, MI. March 19-20, 2003

Collaborative Product Development and SRM Strategies for Aerospace 2003
Bethesda, Maryland. March 17-19, 2003

CAD case studies, CAD user stories
DW Product Development, Inc. : Moldflow Adviser
PocketSpec Technologies Inc. : ColorQA Color Comparison Device
Polymer Technologies : Moldflow
Jada Plastics : Moldflow
British Telecommunications (BT) : GTX
Bose Corporation : Ansoft Corporation

General Interest
Innovation Management
Engineering Change Management
Managing PDM in a changing environment
Principles of Good Product Development

Engineering Data Management Newsletter - November 2002 issue Table Of Contents
CPC/PLM Strategies : 2002

2PLM Media Sheet
Advertisers of CAD, CAM, CAE, EDM, PCM, PDM, PIM, PLM, CPC, CPC/PLM and related systems and solutions. Read the 2PLM Media Sheet. Find out how to reach more than 30,000 customers with one mouse click.

Page 3
* Corporate *
Documentum announced that it has successfully completed its acquisition of privately held eRoom Technology, Inc. Documentum issued approximately 7.77 million shares of its common stock and paid approximately $12.60 million in cash for all of the outstanding shares of eRoom's capital stock. Details

Documentum announced that it has successfully completed its all-cash acquisition of privately held TrueArc Corporation for $3.6 million. Details

Integrated Development Enterprise, Inc., IDe, announced that it secured $13.25 million in venture capital funding from five firms. Details

* Financial *
Firepond, Inc. announced results for its fourth quarter ended October 31, 2002. In the fourth quarter, Firepond reported total revenue of $4.4 million as compared to $4.3 million in the prior quarter and $9.1 million for the same period in the prior year. Details

Framework Technologies announced that it has completed the fourth fiscal quarter of 2002 on September 30th, having achieved record-breaking sales. Details

 Autovue - from Cimmetry Systems, Inc.

Download AutoVue from Cimmetry Systems

Verity, Inc. reported financial results for its second fiscal quarter ended November 30, 2002. Verity's revenues for its second quarter were $22.9 million, representing a 4% sequential increase over first quarter revenues of $22.0 million and a 1% increase from revenues of $22.6 million for the second quarter of last year. Details

* People *
Avatech Solutions announced the appointment of Donald R. "Scotty" Walsh as the company's new chief executive officer. Details

Pragmax Software Corporation announced the appointment of Richard C. Watts as CEO. Details

think3, Inc. announced the addition of three senior executives to its management team. Joining the think3 team are industry veterans Daniel Meyer, vice president of worldwide marketing; James Levison, vice president of finance; and Dean Germeyer, vice president of North American sales. Details

* Implementation *
Ariba, Inc. announced that Yamanouchi Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd. has deployed the Ariba Buyer procurement solution throughout its Japanese operations. Details

Autodesk, Inc. announced that BEA Systems, Inc. has transformed its building project management and facilities management processes with the Autodesk Buzzsaw collaboration service. Details

Baan announced that its iBaan for Product Lifecycle Management (iBaan for PLM) solution has gone live at Unisys Brazil to help streamline and integrate the company's engineering processes. Details

Commerce One announced that Magna Steyr Fahrzeugtechnik has selected Commerce One technology and services to automate its procurement processes. Details

Documentum announced that BD (Becton, Dickinson and Company) has deployed the Documentum ECM platform for Life Sciences. Details

Documentum announced that Honeywell Technology Solutions Inc. has selected the Documentum ECM platform. Details

EDS reported that the LeTourneau Inc. Equipment Group has implemented its Solid Edge CAD system. Details

INCAT announced that Vought Aircraft Industries, Inc., a global provider of aerostructures, has selected I/Check V4 as its corporate standard for checking and ensuring the integrity of CATIA data. Details

Lumeo Software announced that TetraPak is piloting the Lumeo Control Interface with a bottle sterilizer named "Rupert", in search of solutions to aid in early PLC testing. Details

 Myriad and Brava! WebKit from
 Informative Graphics Corporation.

More about Myriad and Brava! WebKit from Informative Graphics Corporation

MSC.Software Corp. announced that Korean rail manufacturer Rotem has increased their use of MSC.Software virtual product development technology and purchased MSC.ADAMS and MSC.ADAMS/Rail. Details

Oculus Technologies announced that The Boeing Company has selected Oculus Technologies to provide its CO software for the DARPA AIM-C project. Details

Open Text Corporation and Impact Innovations Group announced their joint efforts in developing a Livelink-based application for the United States National Archives and Records Administration (NARA). Details

PTC and Airbus announced that PTC Windchill product lifecycle management solutions have been deployed to create the product information backbone of the Airbus A380, the 555 passenger super jumbo aircraft now under development. Details

PTC announced it is supporting Carnegie Mellon University in its drive to give mechanical engineering students a comprehensive understanding of Product Lifecycle Management (PLM). Details

RAND Worldwide announced that Berufsakademien Baden-Wurttemberg (a group of nine German universities of Cooperative Education) has selected the Company to provide 500 seats of CATIA V5 from Dassault Systemes. Details

SolidWorks announced that Belgium's largest industrial design university, Kaho Sint-Lieven, is equipping its engineering students with 3D CAD skills by incorporating SolidWorks software into its curriculum. Details

SolidWorks announced that clamp and gripping device manufacturer DE-STA-CO Industries is using SolidWorks 3D PartStream.NET Internet technology to provide customers with millions of easily downloadable 3D CAD models of products from its online catalog. Details

Speed to Market announced that NDI, a leading supplier of optical tracking equipment, has selected Speed to Market's Concerto Software for managing its product development projects. Details

Speed to Market announced that the 412th Test Wing at Edwards Air Force Base has decided to deploy TOC Project Management and Concerto multi-project scheduling software across seven additional test portfolios as a result of a successful pilot phase. Details

Spescom Software Inc., formerly Altris Software, Inc., announced that the Watford and Bletchley Alliance (WBA) has chosen Spescom Software's eB solution to manage its project documentation. Details

* Developments *
Alibre announced the release of Alibre Design 5.1. Details

Avatech Solutions introduced Proof Positive - a quality assurance software product designed for customers of Autodesk Inventor mechanical design software. Details

Baan announced new capability for manufacturing companies to leverage product-related information throughout an enterprise using the iBaan for Product Lifecycle Management (iBaan for PLM) and Baan's Supplier Relationship Management (SRM) solutions. Details

Cadence Design Systems, Inc. announced that the Cadence Palladium design verification system now has custom interfaces to leading wireless test equipment from Anritsu Corporation, Rohde & Schwarz, and Elektrobit. Details

Cimmetry Systems Inc. announced the release of AutoVue 17. There are many significant new features in AutoVue 17. The AutoVue thin-client solution now provides online real-time Visualization and Collaboration for 2D/3D CAD, EDA and office documents. Details

Cyco Software announced its upcoming AutoManager Publishing Module for Collaborative Web Engineering Solutions. Details

EDS announced the release of Imageware 10, a significantly enhanced software offering from its PLM Solutions line of business providing advanced freeform modeling for automotive class-A surfacing and product styling, reverse engineering and virtual inspection. Details

ICAM Technologies Corporation announced that Messier-Dowty of Velizy, France has purchased CAM-POST Development Licenses for its production facilities in France, United Kingdom and Canada. Details

ITI TranscenData announced the release of CADfix 5.1, the latest version of its CAD data interoperability tool. Details

Lascom announced version 7.0 of Advitium. Details

LMS announced the release of Rev 4.40 of LMS Pimento, the laptop-sized portable analyzer. Details

Moldflow Corporation announced the release of Moldflow Plastics Insight (MPI ) 4.0. Details

Spatial Corp. announced the R10 release of its full line of 3D modeling products. This selection includes the 3D ACIS Modeler (ACIS), 3D ACIS PHL V5, and 3D ACIS Deformable Modeling. Details

Spicer Corporation announced the release of ViewCafé 3.1, featuring significant enhancements to Far East font display and markup features. Details

Synchronicity, Inc. announced the immediate availability of the Synchronicity Publisher Suite version 2.0. Details

Tech Soft America (TSA) announced the release of the latest versions of its HOOPS-based part viewers. Details

VX Corporation announced that the upcoming version 7 of its VX CAD/CAM software will support the leading SpaceMouse and SpaceBall 3D controllers from 3Dconnexion. Details

* Relationships *
Access Commerce announced an OEM agreement with Crystal Decisions. Access Commerce has integrated the reporting technology into its latest release of Cameleon Direct Selling providing Cameleon users added value for reporting and analysis. Details

Autodesk, Inc. announced the first 10 European applications that have met the qualifications of the Autodesk Inventor Certified Application Program (AICAP) for Autodesk Inventor 6 software. Details

Avatech Solutions announced it has been authorized by Autodesk as an Authorized Educational Reseller (AER) to sell products and services to post-secondary educational institutions and students in 48 US states, previously authorized to sell in only 5 states. Details launched the partner program. Details

Cadence Design Systems, Inc. and Acer Foundation announced a strategic alliance in Taiwan. Details

Covisint announced that it has agreed a global strategic relationship with SKF, the world's leading manufacturer of rolling bearings. Details

MatrixOne, Inc. and Formation Systems announced that they are in the process of establishing a joint development and marketing relationship to deliver real-time collaborative product lifecycle management (PLM) software for the consumer packaged goods (CPG) industry. Details

 Spicer View/Mark up - Powerful Performance, Easy to use.

Universal Viewing and Mark Up from Spicer Corporation

Mentor Graphics Corporation announced it has signed Siemens CES Design Services as its first European FPGA Advantage Solutions Thrust (FAST) Partner. Details

MSC.Software Corp. announced an agreement with IBM to market, sell and support the IBM eServer pSeries server product line in the European marketplace. Details

PTC announced it has amended its distribution agreements with RAND A Technology Corporation, which operates as RAND Worldwide in the North America, Western Europe and Asia Pacific regions, effective immediately. Details

Spicer Corporation and RealityWave announced a partnership where RealityWave will embed Spicer viewing technology into its VizStream Platform. Spicer technology will enhance VizStream's extensive 3D CAD model visualization and collaboration capabilities by adding universal viewing for virtually any 2D document, including CAD, vector, raster, and office formats. Details

TTF and OPEN MIND announced the signing of an agreement to deliver applications to the global automotive, aerospace and engineering mechanical industries. Details

* Other *
Alibre Design announced its recent selection for an Editor's Choice Award by CADENCE magazine. Details

EDS and Coleg Sir Gar, (Carmarthenshire College), in Llanelli, South Wales, announced the opening of the college's new EDS Centre for Computer-Aided Engineering. Details

Engineous Software announced the results of the new graduate level Multidisciplinary System Design Optimization class being offered by the Department of Aeronautics & Astronautics at MIT. Details

MatrixOne announced that companies committed to reducing bottom-line costs and improving product introduction processes are succeeding with MatrixOne Program Central. Details

Axis Systems, Inc. and Mentor Graphics Corporation announced they had reached a settlement of their patent litigation. Details

Artemis Resources - PDM Recruitment Specialists

For more information and to see our latest PDM and PLM jobs visit our website

MSC.Software Corp. announced the availability of Mentoring onDemand, a new premium technical support and training service designed to help engineers solve their engineering problems over the phone or Web. Details

Open Text Corporation announced it is the first to receive a tough new security certification for its records management solutions. Details

Proficiency announced that the Company received a CADENCE magazine Editors' Choice Award for the latest release of its Collaboration Gateway Version 2.0. Details

PTC announced that PECO II Inc., a telecommunications power systems and services provider, announced that it has donated solid modeling design software from PTC to four central Ohio educational institutions. Details

QUMAS announced that Deloitte & Touche has recognized QUMAS as Ireland's 10th fastest-growing technology company. Details

RAND Worldwide announced it has earned recognition as a Partner-level supplier for 2002 in the John Deere Achieving Excellence Program. Details

Thetis Technologies Inc. announced that ThetisPro has won Microsoft's Premium .NET Connected certification. Details

Verity Inc. announced that it has been cited as a Top 100 company by two IT business magazines, DM Review and EContent. Details

VX Corporation announced that Version 6.5 of VX CAD/CAM software has earned a Cadalyst magazine All-Star Award. Details

Page 4
Brief lines

Subscription information
To subscribe to 2PLM, fill in the subscription form or send an e-mail headed 'start 2PLM subscription' to

Subscription cost
Subscribers receive 2PLM free of charge.

Privacy policy
We understand and respect your desire for privacy. The information we ask for at subscription time is the minimum necessary to effectively fulfill your subscription and communicate with you if and when necessary. We do not release the information you provide us to third parties. In case of further questions, you can reach us at

Previous issues
Click here to access previous issues of 2PLM.

Limited time
We know you have a busy schedule. To reduce delivery and reading time, 2PLM has a simple format and concise content.

Termination of subscription
To terminate subscription, please send an e-mail headed 'stop 2PLM subscription' to

2PLM is provided free of charge to its readers. Companies that share our objectives of promoting successful implementation of PLM systems and world-class product development performance may sponsor 2PLM. There is space for a maximum of one sponsor message per page, except on this 'Brief lines' page - where there is room for several short sponsor messages.

Publication frequency
2PLM is published approximately every two weeks.

Copyright 2002 by John Stark. All rights reserved.

Links to pages on other sites
Please note we cannot control the content of pages that are not our own.

Permission to reproduce text or graphics
Applications for permission to reproduce part or parts of 2PLM (text or graphics) should be sent to

Permission to make 2PLM available within an organization
Applications for permission to make 2PLM available within a company or other organization (e.g. by internal mail, corporate Intranet, etc.) are usually accepted. Please send a request for permission to

Information provided in 2PLM is intended solely to provide general guidance on matters of interest for the personal use of the reader, who accepts full responsibility for its use. Information is provided 'as is', with no guarantee of completeness, accuracy, or timeliness, and without warranty of any kind, express or implied, including, but not limited to, the warranties of performance, merchantability, and fitness for a particular purpose.

Nothing in 2PLM shall to any extent substitute for the independent investigations and the sound technical and business judgement of the reader. Technology, laws and regulations are continually changing, and can only be interpreted in the light of particular factual situations. The information in 2PLM does not constitute technological, business, legal, investment or consulting advice, and should only be used in conjunction with appropriate professional advice obtained by the reader from a suitably qualified professional who understands the reader's particular factual situation.