February 25, 2002
2PDM

www.johnstark.com


Volume 4
Number 14




Page 1
- Welcome
Page 2
- Update
Page 3
- News
Page 4
- Brief lines

* Welcome *
Welcome to this issue of 2PDM, an e-zine distributed every two weeks on a free subscription basis. This week's article, In Search of the True Product Data is from regular contributor Mike Bryan. Mike's previous article, 'Data quality in the CPC/PLM environment' can be read in the November 5, 2001 issue.

* In Search of the True Product Data *
My first discipline is Engineering Design and I have always thought that this is the most important engineering function there is. And I still believe it, because 70 - 80% of the product cost is bound in at this stage. When I was a young lad (late 1950s) a senior designer told me that I should be aware that every line I drew on the board could result in thousands of pounds of manufacturing costs. I should, therefore, give due thought to every mark I made on the paper.

As I grew in age, and perhaps in wisdom, I began to appreciate also the vital function of the production engineers and their thankless task of converting the design engineers' glorious visions into manufacturable hardware.

Much later on in life, after I had migrated from the drawing board (poor money and prospects) and was wisely working for an aerospace company as CAD Manager, a senior loftsman told me a few home truths. He said that few people realized that the aircraft were not built to the engineering drawings but to the full scale layout drawings that were produced in the Loft. And whereas the engineering drawings were thoroughly checked and signed by Weights, Stress, Aerodynamics, etc., the full scale layout drawings were largely unchecked. During the layout process it was quite likely that changes would have to be made to produce manufacturable components - small changes and not so small changes. Not all of these changes would find their way back to the original engineering drawing, not least because of the conceptual wall that existed between the Drawing Office and the Loft. (And often still exists between Design and Production - usually reinforced by geographic separation.)

I thought about this quite a lot over the following years and I realized that this was only a small part of a much larger problem. Before metal is cut, a number of transformations may be made to the original engineering data during and after their transfer to the supplier e.g., create neutral file, create receiving system file, create manufacturing data and modify manufacturing data. Not all of these transformations may happen but any one of them may result in changes to the original data that are not detected or not recorded. A supplier may well discover problems in the manufacturing data he has created from the file or drawing passed to him along the supply chain. There might be surface gouging or badly defined surface normals or any number of less esoteric problems. He will make local adjustments to these data without necessarily communicating the fact back up the supply chain.

What has all this to do with PDM and PLM? Well, if we are going to store, and indeed archive, product data in these all-encompassing and expensive systems then we need to be pretty sure that what we are storing is what we need to store.

For some years I have preached a minimalist doctrine. That is, with respect to product model data captured in solids, only the original design data needs to be stored. Data for analytical applications may be obtained by applying a function to the design model to create suitable approximations for particular purposes which may be FE analysis, CFD analysis or even stereolithography for prototype manufacture.

Product manufacturing data are, however, a whole different ball-game. Design data represents the intent whereas manufacturing data represents the reality. Customers will check the reality against the intent but to what depth? A solids model represents a complete and unambiguous description. Is that complete description used in its totality to check the manufactured item? The answer is almost certainly no. Does the customer request the manufacturing data to be transferred back? Again, the answer is almost certainly no. Changing the supplier will result in a different reality and this can happen at any point in the supply chain.

I believe that the true "product" data are the manufacturing data and I would like to think that they are nurtured and cosseted. I suspect, though, that for the moment, most of them are buried in suppliers' hard disks, forgotten and unloved. One of my expectations for the much-heralded CPC/PLM vision is that it recognizes the true value of manufacturing data.

Mike Bryan can be contacted at m.bryan@chyanbre.demon.co.uk


Page 2
 Myriad and Brava! WebKit from Informative Graphics Corporation.

More about Myriad and Brava! WebKit from Informative Graphics Corporation



Reference Section
Follow the link for books in the Product Development Library


EDM/PDM World
Follow the links for :

Vendors in the EDM/PDM World. Latest additons/modifications : Configure One, INCAT and Pacific Commerce.

EDM/PDM Conference and seminar organizations

Conferences and Seminars in the EDM/PDM world

Collaborative Product Development and Supplier Relationship Management Strategies for Aerospace
Meet the Joint Strike Fighter Team and other aerospace giants as they discuss CPD and Supplier Relationship Management, Seattle, March 21 - 22.
Call Warren on 1 800 814 3459 ext 324 quoting "2PDM20" for a 20% discount.
www.eyeforaerospace.com/cpd


Factory Automation case studies, Factory Automation user stories
Bayside Automation : Life Cycle Support Services

CAD case studies, CAD user stories
MESSIER-DOWTY : GTX
Coin Acceptors, Inc. : Moldflow Plastics Insight
NASA Glenn Research Center : Ansoft's Maxwell 3D
Viscount Plastics : Moldflow
Others

General Interest

More on Mass Customization and Configurators: Suggested Reading One of our frequent contributors, Dick Bourke, has recently published two articles; one, a broad overview in Computer-Aided Engineering, and the second a review of PTC's new DynamicDesignLink offering in the DTO/ETO portion of the "To-Order" spectrum.
1. Review: "PTC's Windchill Design-to-Order Solution," Desktop Engineering, February 2002, www.deskeng.com
2. "Configuring no two alike," Computer-Aided Engineering, December 2001, www.caenet.com

More on STEP and PDM
Kjell Bengtsson of EPM Technology recommends this article (.pdf) about STEP and PDM.
BTW, inspired by the Norwegian success in the Olympic Winter Games, EPM has decided to give 1% discount for every Gold Medal Norway brings home. As of today this means 10% off all purchased products. More Gold medals, even more discount. This offer ends March 31, 2002.

An individual view of PDM. Follow the link to Eirik Isene's site, Isene PDM Home

Innovation Management
Engineering Change Management
Managing PDM in a changing environment
Principles of Good Product Development


Newsletters
Engineering Data Management Newsletter - January 2002 issue Table Of Contents
CPC/PLM Strategies : 2002



2PDM Media Sheet
Advertisers of CAD, CAM, CAE, EDM, PCM, PDM, PIM, PLM, CPC, CPC/PLM and related systems and solutions. Read the 2PDM Media Sheet. Find out how to reach more than 30,000 customers with one mouse click.

Page 3
News
* Financial *
3D Systems Corp. announced fourth quarter 2001 revenue of $36.7 million compared with $31.7 million in the fourth quarter of 2000, an increase of 16%. Details

Agile Software Corporation announced its financial results for the third quarter of fiscal year 2002, which ended January 31, 2002. Total revenue for the quarter was $18.0 million, compared to total revenues of $25.0 million for the same period in fiscal 2001, a decrease of 28%. Details

Dassault Systemes reported financial results for the fourth quarter and year ended December 31, 2001. Total revenue rose 15% to Euro 225.3 million in the fourth quarter of 2001. For the year ended December 31, 2001 total revenue increased 18% to Euro 746.1 million. Details

Hewlett-Packard Company reported financial results for the first quarter of its 2002 fiscal year ended Jan. 31, 2002. The company reported first quarter revenue of $11.4 billion compared to $10.9 billion in the fourth quarter and $12.4 billion in last year's first quarter. Details

Tecnomatix Technologies, Ltd. announced its financial results for the fourth quarter and full year ended December 31, 2001. For the fourth quarter ended December 31, 2001, the Company is reporting revenues of $21.2 million. This compares to the fourth quarter ended December 31, 2000, when the Company reported revenues of $21.7 million. Details

* People *
Commerce One announced the appointment of Bill Fraine, former senior vice president of worldwide sales for FedEx, as senior vice president and general manager for Commerce One International operations. Robert Singsank, former corporate vice president of worldwide sales for Telcordia Technologies, has been named senior vice president and general manager of the company's Americas sales region. Details

Covisint announced the addition of Marissa Peterson, executive vice president, worldwide operations, Sun Microsystems, Inc. to the company's Board of Directors. Details

EADS Matra Datavision announced the appointment of Jacques Vannier as Chairman of EADS Matra Datavision. Details

LMS International announced the appointment of Greg Hopton to the post of General Manager North America and Mike Albright to the post of Business Development Manager, Engineering Services. Details

LMS International announced that Marc Boonen has been appointed to the post of Vice President Worldwide Sales. Details

 Autovue - from Cimmetry Systems, Inc.

Download AutoVue from Cimmetry Systems

Mentor Graphics Corporation announced that Sir Peter Bonfield, CBE, FREng, has joined the Board of Directors. Details

Nihon Ariba K.K., a majority-owned subsidiary of Ariba, Inc., announced the appointment of Ryo Miyashita as Chief Operating Officer. Details

think3 announced that Toru Kawaguchi has been named President/Representative Director of think3 Japan, in addition to the Vice President position at think3 Inc. Details

* Implementation *
Agile Software announced that Thermo Labsystems and Thermo Clinical Labsystems - leading suppliers of analytical and diagnostic instrumentation equipment and businesses of Thermo Electron have chosen solutions from Agile. Details

Agile Software announced that, to date, over 75 medical device manufacturers - from start-ups to Fortune 500 global companies - have selected Agile's Product Chain Management (PCM) solutions. Details

Ariba, Inc. announced that Aventis Pharma is rolling out the Ariba Buyer eProcurement solution at three major sites worldwide after going live in less than eleven weeks of initial implementation work. Details

Cadence Design Systems, Inc. announced that QLogic Corporation's Network Storage Group has purchased the Quickturn Palladium design verification system. Details

Siemens announced it has made a strategic decision to implement Centric Innovation from Centric Software, and that it has also joined the Centric Software Strategic Advisory Council. As part of the agreement, Siemens Transportation Systems is implementing Centric Innovation at five of its Development Centers throughout Germany and Austria to accelerate and improve railway car design. Details

Volvo, along with IBM and Dassault Systemes, announced that Volvo 3P (Purchase, Planning, Product Development) will standardize all product development for trucks using PLM solutions from IBM and Dassault Systemes, including new CATIA and ENOVIA V5 products. Details

EDS and Jaguar Racing announced they have signed a technology sponsorship agreement through which EDS software will drive the digital design of Jaguar Racing's Formula One cars. Jaguar Racing is using PLM software from EDS for the design and evolution of its race cars. Details

EDS announced a three-year agreement by its PLM Solutions line of business with General Motors Corporation, expanding an existing GM relationship for software and services. Under the terms of this renewal contract, GM will continue to implement software offerings from EDS's PLM Solutions, including Unigraphics, I-man and Product Vision. Details

EDS reported that ALSTOM Power UK Ltd. has selected Unigraphics knowledge-based engineering software from EDS. Details

EDS reported that it has agreed to supply and implement its 3D mechanical CAD Solid Edge software at TransBus International (United Kingdom), part of the Mayflower Group which includes automotive vehicle manufacturers Dennis, Alexander and Plaxton. Details

Rolls-Royce Corporation announced that a cross-functional team including Exostar, CommerceOne and EDS has brought over 180 suppliers online in under three months to transact business electronically through Exostar's SupplyPass product. Details

LMS announced that Renault has selected LMS FALANCS as their company standard Fatigue Life Prediction analysis code. Details

Lumeo Software announced that its global reseller, Rand Worldwide, has sold Lumeo Motion software to MacGREGOR Group AB in Finland. The software will be used for testing the behavior of hatch covers the company designs and manufactures. Details

MatrixOne, Inc. announced that Amersham Biosciences has selected MatrixOne solutions to unify and support their product development processes in R&D and manufacturing engineering, as well as to streamline product information management. Details

 Web-based View-Markup from Spicer Corporation.

Web-based View-Markup from Spicer Corporation

MatrixOne, Inc. announced that Siemens Dematic, the world's largest supplier of production and logistics automation systems, will implement MatrixOne product collaboration solutions. Details

Mentor Graphics Corporation announced that Oki Semiconductor has standardized on Mentor's Calibre physical verification tool for designs in advanced process technologies of .35, .25, .22 and .16 micron. Details

Mentor Graphics Corporation announced that STMicroelectronics has adopted Mentor's IBIS (Input/Output Buffer Information Specification) model development flow for the complete set of I/O pads in its HCMOS8 0.18 micron integrated circuit (IC) library, and its HCMOS9 0.13 micron process library. Details

Mentor Graphics Corporation announced that the Calibre physical verification tool suite was used to successfully verify the design of PolicyEdge, the first 10-gigabit capable services processor, developed by Fast-Chip, Inc. Details

Proficiency announced an agreement with Caterpillar Inc. to deploy its Collaboration Gateway to facilitate greater interoperability between Caterpillar's mechanical design systems. Details

SolidWorks Corp. announced that Italy-based SACMI Group is using SolidWorks 3D CAD software to design equipment, automated systems, fittings, and facilities for the ceramics and packaging industries. Details

Speed to Market, provider of Concerto Advanced Planning & eXecution (APX) software for managing multiple projects and resources, announced that NACCO Materials Handling Group, designer and manufacturer of Hyster and Yale brand lift trucks, will use Concerto to manage its product development. Details

Spescom and De Beers announced the implementation of a document and configuration management solution - based on eB information management software - at the Cape Town headquarters of one of the companies in the multinational mining organisation. Details

Structural Research & Analysis Corp. announced the sale of 25 seats of COSMOS/Works to the California State University, Fresno. Details

Synergis Technologies, Inc. announced that Wink, Incorporated, with corporate offices in New Orleans, Louisiana has selected Synergis Adept software for engineering document management. Details

Tecnomatix Technologies, Ltd. announced that EDAG Engineering + Design AG has purchased 50 eMPower software licenses for use in their German sites. Details

Tecnomatix Technologies, Ltd. announced that Ford Motor Company has signed an agreement to begin implementing Tecnomatix eMPower MPM solutions - including software applications, service and maintenance - in support of efforts to streamline and standardize the global manufacturing process definition throughout most of Ford's lines of business. Details

Vistagy, Inc. announced the selection of FiberSIM software by the Delta Technical Operations Center division of Delta Air Lines. The FiberSIM suite of tools is tightly integrated into CAD systems to create a specialized environment for designing, analyzing, and manufacturing parts made of advanced composite materials. Details

* Developments *
Dassault Systemes announced the availability of Version 5 Release 8 (V5R8) of DELMIA, the 3d PLM integrated solution for digital manufacturing and maintenance processes, resource creation, simulation, and optimization. Details

Documentum announced the availability of Documentum Portlets for BEA WebLogic Portal 4.0. The portlets, developed using Documentum's Portal Integration Pack, are a set of embeddable application components that deliver out-of-box content management capabilities to BEA WebLogic Portal. Details

Documentum announced the release of the Documentum Portal Integration Pack, which enables the integration of enterprise content and content management capabilities with portal applications. Details

EDS released Teamcenter 2.0, a new version of its PLM software solution. Details

IBM and Dassault Systemes announced the availability of ENOVIA Version 5 Release 8 (V5R8). This announcement includes ENOVIA Portal Solutions and Life Cycle Applications (LCA) V5R8 and ENOVIA VPM Version 1 Release 5 enhancements. Details

IBM and Dassault Systemes announced the availability of Version 5 Release 8 (V5R8) of CATIA, the 3d PLM solution for product design, creation, simulation and optimization. CATIA V5 is the product authoring solution within the 3d PLM portfolio. Details

IDEAL.com introduced the "Scan-to-CAD" Version 5.0 Scanning System for scanning, organizing, network viewing, and editing large format scanned drawings. Details

Informative Graphics Corporation announced the latest release of its intranet document publishing software, Net-It Central 5.0. Net-It Central provides push-button intranet publishing of many different document types. Details

Ingenuus Corporation introduced the Smart Integration Gateway and Smart Gates, middleware tools that enable companies using Ingenuus' Smart Suites to integrate easily with most leading external systems and with popular productivity tools. Details

Mentor Graphics Corporation introduced SpeedGate DSV (Direct System Verification), an advanced verification environment for creating application specific integrated circuits (ASIC) and System-on-Chip (SoC) prototypes using off-the-shelf field programmable gate arrays (FPGAs). Details

PTC launched Pro/DESKTOP Express. Details

PTC, together with Groove Networks Inc., demonstrated a new way of working collaboratively. Details

Paraform announced the introduction of Paraform 3.0, the newest release of its pioneering digital form development software. Details

Rasterex announced the release of a new version of RxViewX, a powerful ActiveX control. Details

SolidWorks Corp. announced the SolidWorks Collaboration Edition, which combines Windows-based 3D CAD software with collaboration tools. Details

Spescom Software Inc. announced the launch of its FastTrack engineering drawing management solution targeted at organizations where controlling CAD drawings and their supporting documents is a critical business requirement. Details

A new brand of 3D printer - Dimension - was introduced by Stratasys. Until now, 3D printing equipment allowed testing of a model's form only. Now, designers and engineers can also test for fit and function because the system models with durable ABS plastic. Details

truEInnovations, Inc. announced truEVault, an in-window file management solution designed specifically for Autodesk Inventor 3D design software. Details

* Relationships *
bom.com announced that it has received Solution Partner status from SolidWorks Corporation, recognizing the bom.com SolidWorks Integration Adapter (SWIA). The SWIA enables seamless integration between SolidWorks 3D CAD part, assembly and drawing files and bom.com. Details

CADKEY Corporation announced that it has entered into an OEM Agreement with Numerical Technologies, Inc.to integrate the NC-MATIC Machining Software with CADKEY Mechanical CAD software. Details

Cadence Design Systems, Inc. and Agilent Technologies Inc. announced a multi-year technology alliance. Through this alliance, they expect to develop and market complete integrated solutions to speed the design of ICs for the wireless and wireline communications industries. Details

Cimmetry Systems and TRIRIGA INC. announced that TRIRIGA has licensed Cimmetry's AutoVue for Java technology for use in its TRIRIGA Intelligent Business System, a Web-based solution designed to centrally automate and manage complete large-scale design, development, and construction activities. Details

DMR Consulting, a member of the Fujitsu Ltd. family of companies, announced its support for integration of Open Text's Livelink with CDC Solutions' EZsubs Team. Details

Document Control Systems, Inc. and CDC Solutions, Inc. announced an alliance to provide the life sciences industry with a complete solution to meet FDA e-submissions requirements - the integration of Document Control Systems' MASTERControl FDA Edition and CDC Solutions' EZsubs Team Edition. Details

http://www.cyco.com

Take a Tour!

Documentum and Plumtree Software announced enhanced integration of Documentum's ECM platform with the Plumtree Corporate Portal. Details

Documentum announced a program for application value-added resellers (VARs) which expands its existing Signature Partner Program for system integrator and technology partners. Details

FileNET Corporation announced the recipients of its 2001ValueNET business partner awards. Details

GlobalSpec, Inc. announced a strategic alliance with SolidWorks Corporation. The agreement facilitates the integration of SolidWorks' 3D PartStream.NET CAD technology with SpecSearch Pro, GlobalSpec's specification-driven product discovery system. Details

Hummingbird Ltd. and 5280 Solutions announced the availability of Certified Mail for Hummingbird EIP, an extension product that offers a seamless architecture for secure email distribution of documents. Details

IBM and Dassault Systemes announced that their strategic alliance delivers end-to-end 3D PLM solutions. The delivery of these 3d PLM solutions fosters integration of 3D product content and knowledge on top of a robust technology infrastructure to further enable design collaboration with suppliers, streamlining of production and service processes, and the establishment of a feedback loop between actual customer experiences from sales, marketing and engineering. Details

INCAT announced, with Translation Technologies Inc. (TTI), that it will begin offering TTI's Acc-u-Trans translation service to its engineering and manufacturing clients. Details

Informative Graphics Corporation announced that Entrada Software of Scottsdale, Arizona has signed an OEM agreement to license IGC's collaboration products, Brava! WebKit and inViso, for integration to its Kinnosa traceability solution for manufacturing supply chains and electronic document management systems. Details

LMS International and HKS announced a joint development agreement to tightly integrate LMS's virtual prototyping software Virtual.Lab and HKS's finite element modeling and analysis software, ABAQUS. Details

PTC and TIBCO Software Inc. announced a global strategic alliance in which TIBCO Software will be the preferred provider of pre-packaged business integration solutions for PTC's line of PLM solutions, based on Windchill technology. TIBCO's products will serve as the integration platform to link PTC's solutions with enterprise systems. Details

Staffware launched a global OEM initiative targeting leading ISV's and ASP's in a program that will bring the benefits of business process management to end user organizations' worldwide. Details

truEInnovations announced that Precistems, Incorporated has partnered with truEInnovations to resell and support truEInnovations' file management solutions. Details

VX Corporation announced that it will resell the IMSpost postprocessor software developed by Intelligent Manufacturng Software, Inc. Details

* Other *
Agile Software announced that it has been presented with the 10th Annual Service Excellence Award. Details

Alias|Wavefront announced that its StudioTools computer-aided industrial design (CAID) software was a key contributor in the creation of the official Olympic torch of the 2002 Winter Olympics. Details

CoCreate Software Inc. announced it has provided Georgia Tech with CoCreate OneSpace Solution Suite software and support valued at more than $900,000. Details

Gibbs and Associates, developer of GibbsCAM, announced that they will be demonstrating push-button interoperability between GibbsCAM 2002 and SolidWorks 2001Plus at NDES 2002 held March 18-21 in Chicago, Illinois at McCormick Place. Details

IBM's Global Services PLM division, in association with Dassault Systemes, has announced the creation of Expert Services Centers: a new service concept providing high - level customer problem support. Details

According to the latest Daratech Inc. analysis for 2001, the Process, Power & Offshore division of Intergraph Corporation continues to lead the global plant creation market with a revenue share of 31 percent. Details

Mentor Graphics announced support for the Stratix device family from Altera Corporation. Details

PTC rolled out a business strategy that it believes will enable manufacturing companies to adopt a single-minded focus on product development, and ensure long-term success for the manufacturing sector. Details

Structural Research & Analysis Corp. announced that COSMOS/Works and COSMOS/DesignSTAR are now certified on systems using the AMD Athlon XP and AMD Athlon MP processor for workstations and servers. Details

Sun Microsystems, Inc. announced that according to Gartner Dataquest's Q4 US Server Database Report, Sun remains the number one leader in UNIX/RISC units and revenue by a wide margin. Details

Verity, Inc. announced it was listed as a leader in the Gartner 2002 Enterprise Search Magic Quadrant. Details

Industrial designers are dedicated but highly opinionated users of design software, says a survey sponsored by VX Corporation. Among the key insights gained from the survey: · Ease of use and the quality of surfacing emerge as the most important attributes of design software for industrial designers. · Many designers use multiple design software products and willingly try alternative tools. · Not many designers feel strongly about the need for their tools to be integrated with the Internet. · There is a real split on the issue of cost: many designers object strongly to the cost of design software, while an equal number believe that cost is a non-issue. Details

3D Systems Corp. announced that 3D Systems Inc. and Vantico Inc. have extended to May 1, 2002, the termination date of their distribution and joint development agreements. Details

Page 4
Brief lines


Subscription information
To subscribe to 2PDM, fill in the subscription form or send an e-mail headed 'start 2PDM subscription' to pdm@2pdm.com

Subscription cost
Subscribers receive 2PDM free of charge.

Privacy policy
We understand and respect your desire for privacy. The information we ask for at subscription time is the minimum necessary to effectively fulfill your subscription and communicate with you if and when necessary. We do not release the information you provide us to third parties. In case of further questions, you can reach us at pdm@2pdm.com

Previous issues
Click here to access previous issues of 2PDM.

Limited time
We know you have a busy schedule. To reduce delivery and reading time, 2PDM has a simple format and concise content.

Termination of subscription
To terminate subscription, please send an e-mail headed 'stop 2PDM subscription' to pdm@2pdm.com

Sponsorship
2PDM is provided free of charge to its readers. Companies that share our objectives of promoting successful implementation of EDM and PDM systems and world-class product development performance may sponsor 2PDM. There is space for a maximum of one sponsor message per page, except on this 'Brief lines' page - where there is room for several short sponsor messages.

Publication frequency
2PDM is published approximately every two weeks.

Copyright
Copyright 2002 by John Stark. All rights reserved.

Permission to reproduce text or graphics
Applications for permission to reproduce part or parts of 2PDM (text or graphics) should be sent to pdm@2pdm.com

Permission to make 2PDM available within an organization
Applications for permission to make 2PDM available within a company or other organization (e.g. by internal mail, corporate Intranet, etc.) are usually accepted. Please send a request for permission to pdm@2pdm.com

Disclaimer
Information provided in 2PDM is intended solely to provide general guidance on matters of interest for the personal use of the reader, who accepts full responsibility for its use. Information is provided 'as is', with no guarantee of completeness, accuracy, or timeliness, and without warranty of any kind, express or implied, including, but not limited to, the warranties of performance, merchantability, and fitness for a particular purpose.

Nothing in 2PDM shall to any extent substitute for the independent investigations and the sound technical and business judgement of the reader. Technology, laws and regulations are continually changing, and can only be interpreted in the light of particular factual situations. The information in 2PDM does not constitute technological, business, legal, investment or consulting advice, and should only be used in conjunction with appropriate professional advice obtained by the reader from a suitably qualified professional who understands the reader's particular factual situation.